Book Review: A Fine Balance by Rohinton Mistry

A Fine Balance, by Rohinton Mistry

Nominated for the Booker Prize. On Oprah’s Book Club.

As the Guardian put it, the book is “A masterpiece of illumination and grace. Like all great fiction, it transforms our understanding of life”.

After reading the 600+ pages of the book, one may say that this is an understatement. The essence of the book can be summarized in the words of one of the Yeats-spouting characters: “After all, our lives are but a sequence of accidents – a clanking chain of chance events. A string of choices, casual or deliberate, which add up to that one big calamity we call life”.

However, the story about four strangers, whose lives intersect in a very strange manner, is spell-binding. You can get completely engrossed in their day-to-day struggles, prodded along by a cast of supporting characters, who are as colorful as they are diverse. Even though each of the supporting characters could be spun off into their own story, Mistry brings them in and out of the lives of the main characters with ease, leaving you wondering about what in their lives caused this behavior.

Mistry gives enough attention to detail – describing the surroundings and the daily struggles so well that one wonders how much research was put into the book. Being a Parsi, Mistry’s detailed description of Dina’s life is understandable, but his description of the other two main characters is straight out of a Satyajit Ray movie -at times, it becomes hard to separate fact from fiction.

As Shakespeare says in King Lear, the wheel comes a full circle, in the end.

The human misery is described well, but maybe Mistry wrote this book in a dark frame of mind – there are brief flashes of kindness and gaiety – but most of the book, including its ending, will make you question your emotions.

Definitely not a book to be read on a Spring afternoon, surrounded by vibrant flowers and chirping birds – for that gives a new meaning to life…this is a book to be read when you feeling melancholy – and can empathize with the characters, being a part of their daily struggle for things we take for granted.

So get a glass of good vino, and prepare to dive in the lives of Dina, Ishvar, Maneck and Om – and be ready to shed a tear or two…

– Raj Bhandari

The DFW Desi, Vol. 200

reflections from

This is a landmark issue of
the newsletter – starting
with a small personal list in
2001, this labor of love
has come a long way eight
years later – thanks to all of
our 18,000+ active readers
for their support and
However, as we move
forward, we need to see
where we can use the latest
technology to bring you
what I think you want –
pertinent news, in a concise
format, when you want it…
So for this issue, we will do
an experiment – instead of
emailing the newsletter to
the list, we will make it
available via a link, the blog
and facebook – see options
below – and we will monitor
how you like it…please give
your feedback, and how
what you’d like to see in the
next versions of this

…thanks again, and happy
web 2.0! (on facebook:
DFW Desi, Twitter:

Full newsletter here

feedback/suggest articles

I’d like the finest please…

“We send the cheapest of these sarees,” he says, pointing to some that are hanging at his by-appointments-only set up on the ground floor of his Defence Colony home, to places down south like Chennai and “they are unable to sell them”. Then, there’s a friend, he says, who had opened an ambitious outlet in Chandigarh. A stylish Bollywood star had been called in for the launch and the entire city, it seemed, turned up. But the store had to shut just a couple of months down the line. There were, apparently, no buye.

The aim of this meeting has been to talk about Bajaj’s attempts at setting up a wine bar in New Delhi, in conjunction with his existing café in GK that was set up in consultation with restaurateur Ritu Dalmia. The bar aims at selling wines exclusively; maybe a single malt or two but nothing beyond. It will have a big selection of wines by the glass, most of them imported, “just one Indian because, I know, when expats or foreigners come to India, they look for Indian wine,” says Bajaj, who is more a champion of Italian wine than Indian wine…